The Business of PIV Disputes

Track 1 — Legal Spend Management: Best Practices for Budgeting Pharmaceutical IP Litigation – Monitoring Legal Spend and Balancing the Budget

Track 2 — Revisiting Damages in an At-Risk Launch Scenario: Questions of Remedies and Valuation

April 20, 2023 10:00am

Track 1

Peter Waibel
Head, Patent Litigation (US)
Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation

Douglas H. Carsten
Partner
McDermott Will & Emery

Track 2

Andrew Cochran
Attorney
Cahill Gordon & Reindel LLP

Vikram Mathrani
Partner
Honigman LLP

Ted Mathias
Partner
Axinn, Veltrop & Harkrider LLP


Track 1 — Legal Spend Management: Best Practices for Budgeting Pharmaceutical IP Litigation – Monitoring Legal Spend and Balancing the Budget
  • Accounting for inflation and implementing practices to minimize surprises and increase predictability
  • Forecasting the budget by phase and quarter
    • Strategies for reevaluating the use of task codes
  • Deciding what components should be incorporated into the budget
    • Vendors
    • Experts
  • Understanding the source of error when unforeseen events or overages occur
  • Evaluating the appropriateness of alternative fee arrangements

Track 2 — Revisiting Damages in an At-Risk Launch Scenario: Questions of Remedies and Valuation
  • Exploring questions of royalties, lost profits, and exceptional findings
    • Market reconstruction considerations
    • Alternatives for noninfringement
    • Examining the value of the use of the patented technology
  • Examining grounds for mitigation
  • Considering the practical consequences of the Supreme Court’s WesternGeco decision on Hatch- Waxman damages awards
    • Exploring when U.S. patent owners may recover foreign lost profits tied to domestic acts of infringement under § 271(f)(2)
    • Examining cases where the relevant infringing conduct occurred in the United States